Crossbody vs. Shoulder Bag: What’s the Difference?

Choosing the right bag elevates any look from fine to fashionable. But how do you know the “right” bag? Sure, maybe you’ll know it when you see it, but there’s more to it than just lucking into the right choice. 

Choosing between a shoulder bag and a crossbody bag may seem an entirely intuitive fashion choice, but there are key factors and practical guidelines you can master to help you make the stylish choice every time. Today, we’ll focus on how to know when to wear a crossbody vs. a shoulder bag.

First, let’s explore the differences between crossbody and shoulder bags, using iconic examples from Chanel and Hermès to illustrate our discussion. Understanding the nuances between these bag types will help you to find the ideal accessory for any occasion.

Crossbody vs. Shoulder Bag: Understanding the Basics

Before delving into the fashion and styling questions comparing crossbody vs. shoulder bags, let’s get down to basics.

What is a crossbody bag?

A crossbody bag has a long strap, allowing the bag to be worn across the body, with the strap on one shoulder and the bag resting on the opposite hip. This design distributes the bag’s weight evenly across your body and keeps it more secure from would-be thieves. Like a shoulder bag, a crossbody bag leaves your hands free throughout the day. 

The look is contemporary and a bit edgy, more casual than a shoulder bag. The Hermès Evelyne is a perfect example of a designer crossbody bag. The long, adjustable canvas strap can be configured to be worn from your shoulder or crossbody. Imagine your favorite jeans, a crisp button-down shirt, a cotton blazer, and moto boots. Then, add a crossbody bag in a pop of color for the win.

What is a shoulder bag?

A shoulder bag also has a long strap and is worn over one shoulder. Unlike a crossbody bag, it hangs straight down from the shoulder to rest at your side, typically at a level somewhere between your ribs and hip. 

A shoulder bag has a more elegant and refined look than a crossbody bag. The iconic Chanel Flap bag is a classic designer shoulder bag. When going to dinner or cocktails in a little black dress, pair it with a shoulder bag.

A critical distinction between crossbody vs. shoulder bags is that all crossbody bags can be worn as shoulder bags, but the reverse is not necessarily true. A crossbody bag requires a longer strap to fit comfortably across the body on the opposite hip.

Now, let’s consider the structural differences between shoulder and crossbody bags.

Difference Between Crossbody and Shoulder Bags: Key Features

We’ve seen that shoulder and crossbody bags share similarities. Now, let’s explore the differences. As mentioned above, a primary difference in crossbody vs. shoulder bags is strap length. While the best crossbody strap length for you will depend upon your height and size, a strap of 45” to 55” or a drop of 20” to 25” fits most women. For petite women 5’2” and shorter, an 18” drop can fit crossbody, achieving that effortless look. Shoulder bags, meanwhile, typically have a drop of 8” to 12”. This allows the bag to nestle nicely under your arm, adding a touch of elegance to any ensemble.

Another difference between shoulder bags and crossbody bags is the size of the bag compartment. A shoulder bag can range from tiny to quite large, yet fit comfortably at your side. For a crossbody bag, however, the compartment should be relatively small, both for comfort and to avoid overpowering the look. A large Chanel Deauville Shopping Tote measures over 20 inches across and makes a chic shoulder bag. Chanel crossbody bags, however, typically measure 8 inches or less in width.

The final distinction between crossbody and shoulder bags is in the structure. A shoulder bag can accommodate a bulky bag or one with a rigid structure because it is worn at your side. For instance, the highly structured Goyard Saigon is a stylish shoulder bag. However, a crossbody bag should be soft-sided and slim to better fit against your body. If a bag is awkward, doesn’t fit,  or is uncomfortable to wear crossbody, it can never achieve the carefree look you want. 

When To Choose a Crossbody vs. Shoulder Bag?

Both shoulder and crossbody bags leave your hands free, allowing you greater freedom of movement than when you wear a clutch or handbag. A crossbody bag emphasizes function and is suitable for streetwear when you’re on the go, possibly bobbing and weaving your way down a busy sidewalk or running errands. It is ideal for sightseeing, sporting events, walking tours, concerts, festivals, and shopping. A shoulder bag, however, speaks of elegance and is better suited to a slower pace. You’ll wear a shoulder bag to the office, on a dinner date, at a cocktail party, attending a wedding, brunching, or at a party. 

Finding Your Perfect Crossbody or Shoulder Bag

So, which should you choose for your next luxury bag— a crossbody or shoulder bag? First, consider your lifestyle. If you tend to dress casually, are often on the go, and prioritize practicality, a crossbody bag is the best choice. If you prefer a polished, sophisticated look, your calendar has many dressy events, and you value timeless elegance, choose a shoulder bag. Of course, many Chanel shoulder bags have sufficiently long or adjustable straps that can be worn both ways, saving you from the choice!

Whether you choose a crossbody vs. a shoulder bag, there is no better source than Madison Avenue Couture. Explore Hermès crossbody bags and shoulder bags in a wide range of colors and styles, as well as those by Chanel, Dior, Fendi, Goyard, and Louis Vuitton.